The danger of pessimism fatigue - FT中文网
登录×
电子邮件/用户名
密码
记住我
请输入邮箱和密码进行绑定操作:
请输入手机号码,通过短信验证(目前仅支持中国大陆地区的手机号)。如果该手机号尚未注册,将自动创建 FT中文网账号。短信可能需要几分钟送达,验证码15分钟内有效,请耐心等待:
请您阅读我们的用户注册协议和隐私权保护政策,点击下方按钮即视为您接受。
FT商学院

The danger of pessimism fatigue

Too many have cried wolf about too many things and the public is now perilously nonchalant
00:00
{"text":[[{"start":5.86,"text":"Dinner at Legado. It has been open for more than a year, so should be losing impetus. Instead it is elbow-to-elbow full on a Wednesday evening, with double sittings. As of this week, it is trading on Mondays to meet demand. And so begins the conversation that marks many a night out in 2026: “Who are all these people?” “How are they funding this?” Most of all: “Why does no one look haunted?”"}],[{"start":29.36,"text":"There is a 10 per cent chance that AI will cause human extinction, according to some in the field. Off the record, spies quote similar odds on a pan-European war this decade. And still I, like REM, feel fine. The Homeric struggle to get a restaurant table between 5.30pm and 9.45pm suggests that others do too. What explains the gap between the precariousness of the world right now and the majestic nonchalance out there?"}],[{"start":56.68,"text":"Pessimism fatigue, I fear. In recent times, too many boys have cried “wolf” — or “crime wave” or “loneliness epidemic” or “civilisational erasure” — and the townsfolk are numb to it now. Doom merchants are not just a drag to be around. They are bad citizens, insofar as their round-the-clock bleakness makes it hard for others to distinguish the real threats from the neurotic slop."}],[{"start":79.48,"text":"A westerner of my age has lived through the following public scares. First, nuclear annihilation. In the 1980s, it was the stuff of Hollywood films and Martin Amis’s weakest writing. Turns out the cold war was ending, not turning hot. Second, al-Qaeda. The threat was not invented but nor was it ever remotely existential. That era’s political speeches have aged mortifyingly. Third, the pandemic, or rather the lockdown, which was going to change human interaction forever. It was an open question whether even the handshake would return, never mind sex. Both have, I hear."}],[{"start":null,"text":"

When a president is called fascist and turns out to ‘just’ be wrong and venal, we will have our guard down when an authentic fascist creeps into view

"}],[{"start":113.62,"text":"There was no malice behind the raising of these alarms. But the effect, which has been to desensitise people to other warnings, is poisonous. You are likelier to shrug at the mention of Vladimir Putin if you regret not shrugging at the mention of Saddam Hussein. You might feel licensed to belittle climate concern if you remember expert-sounding talk of an eternal pandemic."}],[{"start":134.44,"text":"At least the panics of yesteryear were founded on large, concrete events: Pershing missile deployments, 9/11, a coronavirus. In vogue now is a psychocultural gloom — the “crisis of masculinity”, “post-literacy” — built on selective data, pop science and a sort of rhetorical overexcitement that starts to bounce off the audience. At some point, people cross-reference the misery of the “discourse” with their experience of three-dimensional life, in which quite a lot is better than it was a generation ago. The resulting loss of trust, the tuning-out of warnings, even valid ones, is fatal."}],[{"start":171.2,"text":"In the past, this column has argued against pessimism for being quite often wrong. And it is. The quickest route to applause from a dappy audience is to pine for some Edenic past, then give a monocausal explanation — Thatcher, smartphones — for the subsequent decline. The middlebrow-ness, the incuriosity about positive social trends, is infinite. Crime has halved since the 1990s and none of these sourpusses want to talk about it."}],[{"start":198.2,"text":"But this column is different. Its case against pessimism is utilitarian: that it has bad real-world consequences. Despair is dangerous because, over time, if it is falsified more often than not, it makes us less vigilant, not more. When a president is called fascist and turns out to “just” be wrong, inept and venal, people will have their guard down when an authentic fascist creeps into view."}],[{"start":220.76,"text":"The culprit in Aesop’s fable is not the lying boy. It is the villagers, who make the inductive error of disbelieving all wolf sightings because the previous ones were false. A classic Humean no-no, that. People shouldn’t do it. But we do. And so the ethical burden is on pessimists to tone things down. Even fairly plausible warnings have to be rationed, to avoid becoming an ignorable white noise. I see the problem most nights. I am the problem most nights, laughing into the gambas al ajillo at what might be the darkest moment since 1945. “Why does no one look haunted?” Perhaps they once did, and feel like fools for it."}],[{"start":267.64,"text":""}]],"url":"https://audio.ftcn.net.cn/album/a_1791680333_9515.mp3"}
版权声明:本文版权归FT中文网所有,未经允许任何单位或个人不得转载,复制或以任何其他方式使用本文全部或部分,侵权必究。

火箭、机器人和风险:马斯克的3.6万亿美元豪赌

全球首富试图促成迄今最大胆的一笔合并交易,但他还需要说服股东和全球监管机构。

埃博拉疫情扩散至西非,世卫组织发布警报

尼日利亚当局正紧急追踪一名本迪布焦型埃博拉病毒检测呈阳性者的数十名密切接触者。

让美国国务卿感兴趣的印度大型炼油厂

在白宫努力应对中期选举前燃油价格高企之际,特朗普的首席外交官鲁比奥将拜访信实工业董事长安巴尼。

投资方寻求退出渠道,运动品牌新贵Castore积极接洽中国买家

获安迪•穆雷爵士和吉姆•拉特克利夫爵士支持的英国品牌正与安踏、李宁及美国鞋履品牌洽谈出售事宜。

中国如何打破西方的电池壁垒

保护主义壁垒不断抬高之际,中国企业正加速打造全球供应链。

伊朗战争使全球石油力量平衡向美洲倾斜

随着买家竞相寻找替代来源,以弥补霍尔木兹海峡航运受阻造成的供应损失,南北美国家的石油投资和产量均大幅增长。
设置字号×
最小
较小
默认
较大
最大
分享×